TIGblogs TIG | TIGblogs GROUP TIGBLOGS LOGIN SIGNUP
KarstenWenzlaff
KarstenWenzlaff
No thank you, please sit down - Debating in Cambridge

Last night I went to the Cambridge Union Society, a debating club that has existed for more than a century, upheld the tradition of free speech and attracted numerous great speakers.

The first debate discussed whether fat Children should be taken away from their parents. Two speakers argued in favor, and two against. The rules of debating are very complex. Speeches are limited to a certain amount of time and interventions have to be granted by the speaker. In fact, the speaker can refuse an intervention by either politely saying “No, thank you” or are little bit rougher “Denied”.

The quality of the speeches and as well as the interventions were impressive. Short, to the point, witty, often spontaneously reacting to the development of the debate. And mind this, most participants were undergraduates which just started their university education.

The second debate of the evening discussed whether Nuclear Energy could be a solution to Climate Chance. A local Member of Parliament, a representative from Friends of the Earth and the winner of the world debating championship spoke against the issue, and a representative from the British Nuclear Industry, the Carbon Zero Society, and an engineer which flew to the North Pole in a hot-air ballon demanding nuclear energy spoke in favour.

The debate was very intense, lasted about two hours and a half without intermission. Expert statements and careful ridicul of the opposing sides followed each other. And again I was impressed how little shyness the students expressed when disagreeing with the experts.

The set-up of the room was such that both sides were sitting opposed to each other which creates a very intimate debating atmosphere. Even without microphones every word could be understood. And at the end, the audience was invited to vote on the issue by exciting through doors labelled “Aye” and “Noe”. I voted no, simply because I am quite happy that Germany stopped nuclear energy, even though it will take 30 years to turn off all of them.


October 5, 2007 | 6:10 AM Comments  0 comments

Tags:
You must be logged in to add tags.


Karsten Wenzlaff's Profile

Karsten Wenzlaff's Friends


Latest Posts
…and arrived in...
… off to Obama
Homer Simpson votes...
McCains Apocalypse
if you haven’t...

Monthly Archive
April 2006
October 2006
November 2006
December 2006
January 2007
February 2007
March 2007
April 2007
May 2007
June 2007
July 2007
August 2007
September 2007
October 2007
November 2007
December 2007
January 2008
February 2008
March 2008
April 2008
June 2008
July 2008
August 2008
September 2008
October 2008

Change Language


Tags Archive
and bits bitsandbytes blogandweb2.0 books bytes cambridge echologist economics education election europe facebook funny g8 kasi-blog kasiblog lobbyism media obama personal politics russiaandtheeast socialnets(studivzetc.) socialnetworks tools travels trinityhall usa youtube

Friends
ABHIPRAYA
Adrian Pintilie
AfricanCherub!
Agnieszka Tatera
Alaa Isam Hassan
Anto Liivat
BYJF
Chichi
Christophe
Damian Profeta
Dumisani Nyoni
Dumitru Garstea
Edward Popoola
Erik Styffe
eva gatwiri
Fabian Johr
Franziska Seel
Gavz
Henry Ekwuruke
Jean
Jenny Lind D. Elmaco
joyce
Khalid Khawaldeh
KINGSLEY
kolawole osinowo
Lindsey Higgs
Lukonge John.
Marc Ludwig
Marc Nebelung
Mariana Ballestero
Marouen
Martin G. Viehöver
Martín Miguel Arias
Mathew
MBUNZAMA NARCISSE
Moses 2005
Moustafa Mohamed Hussein
Niraj Shekhar
Peculiar
Rick
ROSE MATIKO UBWE
Sandra Atler
Siim Sikkut
Simon Orie
Tatiana V. Balyuk
Tino Kreutzer
Tunisian
Uday Rosario
Ukoha Nnenna
Yves Regez


35846 views
Important Disclaimer